Back to de minimis AI use

De minimis AI use for photographers

Proudly Human’s use of the legal phrase ‘de minimis’ follows the lead of the US Copyright Office. The Copyright Office’s view is that copyright can only protect the product of human creativity. Thus, works submitted for copyright protection must not have more than de minimis AI-generated content. The term itself is the short form of the legal principle known as “de minimis non curat lex,” which means “the law does not take notice of very small or trifling matters.” The Proudly Human de minimis standards are our own, developed through wide and deliberative debate. We define specific de minimis standards for each category of creative works.

The use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) as a research assistant is permitted for photographers of ProudlyHuman™ certified photography. For example, you may use AI to search for facts, summarize ideas, analyze data, generate ideas, or suggest directions for further development.

The use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) as a research assistant is permitted for photographers of ProudlyHuman™ certified photography. For example, you may use AI to search for facts, summarize ideas, analyze data, generate ideas, or suggest directions for further development.

AI must not be used for the generation of non‑trivial content that is directly incorporated into the final work. All creative expression and authorship must remain the original contribution of the human creators.

Specifically, your use of AI must be limited to de minimis levels. That is, uses so minor or mechanical that they do not affect the copyrightable authorship of your work and, in practical terms, do not alter its human‑created nature.

Acceptable de minimis AI use

  • Generating ideas or high‑level concepts

  • Research into facts and prior commentary on the topic, akin to what a human research assistant would do.

  • Technical tasks such as sharpening an image, colour correction, noise reduction, or blurring faces in video

Unacceptable AI use (beyond de minimis)

  • AI‑generated design elements or creative content that meaningfully contributes to the final work

  • AI‑generated material that would be copyrightable if created by a human

  • AI‑generated visual art, illustrations, special effects, or imagery

  • Using AI to remove elements of an image

Certify your work as human

Show readers, listeners and viewers that a human created it.

Apply for free

Support the Proudly Human movement.