The chief executive of generative AI audio platform, Suno, said last month that it is now “far beyond” the 2 million subscribers it disclosed in February. Many soldiers in this growing army of AI prompters willingly forgo songwriting to fast‑track the song. Output without input. Yet creating art requires art work; it is the effort that earns the climax. The same can be said of sex. It follows that those using AI to generate a song would prefer their orgasm sans sex. I have therefore concluded: I don’t need to sleep with AI prompters to know they’re bad in bed.
The charm of the orgasm is self‑evident. The charm of sex is less so. It is a complex and delicate thing. The things said about making love are the same things said about making songs. Both require seduction, patience, risk‑taking, attention to detail and practice. Both can leave you insecure one moment and ecstatic the next.
The sacred mechanics of music‑making are coveted by students and masters alike. Producer and songwriter, Dr. Dre, is one such master. And yet, this month, Dre told his former N.W.A bandmate Ice Cube he is “extremely excited” about AI. Appearing on the first episode of Cube’s new podcast, Listen & Laugh, Dre was asked whether he would mind a producer using AI to mix a record like Dr. Dre. No, he said: “as a creative force and as an innovator, I could not be mad at that. I would respect that.”. Cube was less convinced. He backed creators using AI tools, but not computers taking “total control”. It was not Dre’s first endorsement. In August, he told the New York Times he is “embracing” AI in his music production.
Now, I don’t need to work with Dr. Dre to know he is good in the studio. Hired time and time again to produce era‑defining records by the likes of 2Pac and Mary J. Blige, Dre has innovated his way to the Mount Olympus of modern music. In short – Dre understands that critical music is earned by effort.
Playing AI hype tag‑team with his longtime business partner, legendary producer Jimmy Iovine, Dre told Times reporter Jordyn Holman, “It’s a new tool for creativity”. The ‘AI is a tool’ argument holds that AI is to the user as the paintbrush is to the painter. Or indeed, a drum machine is to the record producer. This misunderstands what a tool is. A tool is animated by human skill and commitment. Together, human and tool achieve what neither could do alone. AI can generate songs with no human involved at all; another AI can write the prompt. And when the user does write a prompt, AI does the work.
Genuine tools for creation demand more of the creator than a prompt; the sculptor does not instruct the marble to politely reveal its marvel. A drum machine gathers dust until a human programs the elements which make the groove groovy. Suno requires as little as a single word prompt to generate audio. Generative AI is less a tool than it is an appliance. More dishwasher than drill.
When AI generates the music, the user surrenders creative control, then admires the output and claims it as their own. The world’s AI acolytes would push back on that statement. They don’t characterise AI use as relinquishment of creative control. Bafflingly, they argue that, though the machine generated the audio and they contributed only a prompt, they are the product’s author. The work of AI is their own. To take this argument seriously is to agree that I, after dropping off my nephew at his Little League final, buying dog food and watering the tomatoes, deserve credit for hitting the winning home run in the final inning.
Often delivered in the same breath as the ‘AI is a tool’ argument is the ‘AI is just another tech disruption’ position. In Dre’s words: “I had a discussion with a few people a few days ago. They were against A.I. and I’m like, ‘OK, you sound like the person that would have been against the drum machine when it came out.’ Or synthesizers, right?”
Human‑created music has endured wave after wave of technological disruption. It is true that the drum machine, Auto‑Tune and the synthesiser did not kill music; they were enabling forces that made music more dynamic. However, to assume music will survive AI, and indeed will thrive, is false and dangerous. The AI disruption is a unique threat.
If AI‑generated material continues to masquerade as human‑created art, the consumer may forget that the human behind the song, frame, or book cover is what makes it compelling. In July, Deezer reported that in June it received nearly 90,000 fully AI‑generated tracks a day, more than half of all new uploads on peak days. Nor can that figure capture what I call studio‑washed AI: AI‑generated songs re‑recorded by human musicians to pass as their own. AI music, or human‑created work, must be labelled. On that same podcast, Ice Cube held up an old record bearing the parental advisory sticker he credits N.W.A with inspiring, and proposed a label for the AI age: “AI generated, human generated”. Such a label acts as a beacon to help music‑lovers make an informed decision.
Dre, in response to the question from The Times, “So you’re using A.I. when you’re producing?”, said, “Yes, I’m using it. Again, as a tool to see what it would do with what I just did”. So, the scale of Dre’s AI use in the studio is unclear. Is it possible Dre allows AI to demonstrate the creative path not taken, and duly ignores it? Yes. It is possible. But is it possible to maintain creative control of an AI‑generated audio track? No. Lose creative control and you forfeit authorship. The pleasure goes with it. For it is the work of art that gives the art its meaning. As it is the making which makes the love worth making.